Pictures of Insect Men: A Retrospective Analysis of the Mimic Trilogy
This week marks the release of the Mimic director's cut on Blu-ray, which includes all sorts of brand new goodies. I haven't gotten my copy yet, but I will soon. I heard that even though the new cut still doesn't have the ending that Guillermo del Toro wanted, it's closer to his original vision than the theatrical cut. I've also heard that del Toro's commentary track provides a lot interesting details as to how Mimic became less about what he wanted and more about what the producers wanted. (Then again, I don't think that the new director's cut further explores one of Mimic's grimly funny ideas, that a population of giant carnivorous insects could grow under the very nose of America's largest city but as long as the critters stay in the shadows and relegate their carnivorous diet to society's outcasts--the homeless, stray animals, and larger vermin such as rats--no one would really notice.)
Until I can put my two cents in about the new cut, here's a (slightly edited) reprint of an article I wrote that was originally posted on PopPolitics.com back in 2008. It's a retrospective of the entire Mimic trilogy, the original 1997 movie and its two direct-to-DVD sequels. All three movies were loosely inspired by a short story of the same name that was written by Donald A. Wolheim in 1942. This article examined how concepts and issues that are specific to genetic research and their related environmental impacts permeate the Mimic films, thus making them different from their irradiated Atomic Age "Big Bug" predecessors and worthy of unique consideration. Read on ....
For those of you who are not familiar with the Mimic trilogy, here's a summary of each film:
* Mimic (1997): The film begins with children in New York City dying in droves because of Strickler's Disease, a respiratory illness that was found to be transmitted by the common cockroach. To eradicate the disease, entomologist Dr. Susan Tyler (Mira Sorvino) genetically engineers the Judas Breed, an insect species designed to eradicate Strickler's Disease by attracting and killing the roaches, and then dying off when their intended purpose is fulfilled. Three years later, a series bizarre deaths and occurrences lead Tyler to discover that the Judas Breed didn't die after all, but mutated into six-foot tall, sewer-dwelling predators that have the capability to visually 'mimic' their prey: human beings.
* Mimic 2: Hardshell (2001): A lone male Judas Breed relocates a horde of Judas Breed larvae (presumably the offspring of the Judas Breed nest from the first film) into the basement of a run-down NYC school, a school where Remi Panos (Alix Koromzay), Dr. Tyler's assistant from the first film, teaches science classes. During the course of the story, Remi learns that not only is the monster stalking her and killing her potential boyfriends with the intent of making her the queen of his new nest, but that this particular Judas Breed has also gotten much better at mimicking humans.
* Mimic 3: Sentinel (2003): Marvin Montrose (Karl Geary) is the protagonist, a survivor of the Strickler's Disease epidemic in the first film. The illness had left his health in such poor condition that he has been restricted to living with his family in a dilapidated apartment building in the NYC slums. Limited to his room and a hobby of voyeuristic photography, he notices suspicious activity in his building suggesting that a nest of Judas Breed monsters are feeding on his neighbors.
The Mimic films are Big Bug movies, a horror movie sub-genre that is largely regarded as a relic of American 1950s cinema. Insects are the ideal choice for evoking fear in films, because their general appearance--multiple eyes, coarse hairs, and a seemingly endless arrangement of twitching legs, mandibles, antennae, and wings--is enough to make anyone's skin crawl and the Mimic films use those attributes to great effect. However, the plot device of man’s dominance over nature being challenged by oversized animals has been with cinema since its early days, in films such as the silent adaptation of Arthur Conan Doyle's The Lost World (1925) and the early monster classic King Kong (1933).
While other animals have gotten nasty cases of gigantism through reckless science in the sci-fi/horror genre, movies where insects and arachnids become the giants emphasize both the absurdity and the alienating horror of the big beast narrative. The absurdity comes with something so small becoming so impossibly large, while the alienation and horror come from the idea of coming face to face with something so repulsive and inhuman and yet so deeply embedded within the natural world. Indeed, movies where people are attacked by giant insects--particularly as by-products of scientific negligence--could be seen as a statement of how alienated humanity has become from the natural world and its most abundant inhabitants: the insects.
A common plot device for Big Bug movies is that something related to atomic power, either in the form of atomic bomb testing or scientific research involving radiation, causes insects or arachnids to grow to mammoth proportions. Even though atomic power is blamed for gigantism in the Big Bug movies, their most obvious literary predecessor is H.G. Wells' 1904 novel The Food of the Gods and How it Came to Earth, where giant rats, worms and wasps are the result of careless chemical testing on food supplies.
Some have dismissed the Mimic films as just updated versions of the Big Bug movie, particularly Them! (1954), with "genetic tampering" replacing "atomic radiation" as the public phobia du jour. However, a significant difference between the Mimic films and their predecessors and counterparts is the location of the monsters' origin. Where most Big Bug movies feature the monsters originating in some remote location (a desert, a cave, even the arctic) and then later posing a threat to a large human population, the Mimic monsters are purely creatures of the city: it is where they were created, evolved, and reside in all three movies.
The shift in location of the man-made monsters' birthplace in Big Bug movies could be a reflection of the shift in how people view the idea of environmental corruption: modern ecological awareness has led many to see the problem of environmental corruption as something happening within one's own living environment. The 20th century saw a number of health hazards associated with urban living, including asbestos, lead paint, inadequate waste disposal, and vermin such as bed bugs. In fact, the cockroach-spread Strickler's Disease in the Mimic movies is sort of an exaggerated nightmare of research findings that indicate how cockroach allergens contribute to the increase in asthma cases in urban areas.
The internalization of ecological concerns into urban settings is symbolized in the Judas Breed's appearance. Most other Big Bugs are just a species of insect or arachnid made large, either the size of a car or bigger; once these monsters are found by the protagonists, they are hard to miss. In contrast, the Judas Breed can walk among us unnoticed--in dark subway stations, alleys, and slums--due to their human-mimicking ability.
There is something oddly compelling about the Judas Breed's shape-changing: unlike the near-flawless pod clones from the Invasion of the Body Snatchers movies or the various types of humanoid robots from the Terminator series, the Judas Breeds' ability to imitate humans is both limited and clumsy, only effective in shadows or at a distance. The Judas Breeds' appearance when they imitate humans is like when insects imitate twigs, leaves, or other insects. Seeing this natural survival strategy become part of an artificial, urban environment gives it an exotic, alien aura, further emphasizing the theme of humanity's disconnect from nature. The overall effect of the Judas Breed's deception was best described by Roger Ebert in his review of Mimic: "We're instinctively frightened when an entity looks like one thing and suddenly reveals itself as something else. ... As for the insect predators, what they have learned to mimic, and how they do it, provides one of the best payoff shots in the movie."
Then again, the end result of the Judas Breeds' metamorphosis provides a commentary of its own. The insects look like a giant mantis/termite/cockroach crossbreed with various exoskeletal growths that, when shifted around, appear to look like something vaguely human. Their malformed appearance symbolizes the increased media coverage in recent years of the horrible disfigurement of animals that have been subjected to chemical poisoning, resulting in fish and frogs with multiple limbs or hermaphrodite anatomies. It also reflects modern biological experimentation that has allowed scientists in 1997 to grow human ears on the backs of mice and genetic research that incorporated jellyfish DNA into rabbits and pigs, resulting in glow-in-the-dark animals.
As Big Bug movies go, the Mimic movies have much in common with the The Fly (1958), its 1986 remake, and their various sequels when it comes to the narrative and visual themes of insect and human worlds suddenly fusing together in haphazard, grotesque arrangements that are horrifying, preposterous and tragic in equal measures. For example, the title monster of the original Fly movie is somewhat like the Judas Breed, in the sense that both are genetically-spliced, underground-dwelling, human-sized monsters who hide their insect identities behind awkward, makeshift masks. There are parallels between the classic scene in The Fly, when Helene Delambre (Patricia Owens) pulls the hood away from her husband's head only to see the enlarged face of a housefly, and in Mimic, when Dr. Tyler suddenly sees a full-sized Judas Breed insect unwrap itself out of its human disguise for the first time.
The Fly/Mimic connection is more evident in Mimic 2, which is essentially The Fly in reverse: instead of a man becoming more like an insect, Mimic 2 features an insect slowly becoming more like a man. The ending of Mimic 2, when Remi's Judas Breed admirer shows up at her front door to 'date' her, is likewise very similar to the freakish imagery in The Fly movies.
If the Mimic movies have anything in ample supply, it's irony. The most obvious irony is in the creation and development of the Judas Breed themselves: they were created as bugs that could 'fool' real cockroaches for the purpose of killing them, and then they mutated into something that can 'fool' people for a similar predatory purpose. Likewise, with their original intent as a solution to Strickler's Disease, the Judas Breed put a new ironic spin on the term 'superbug', a term coined to describe an infectious bacterium that is antibiotic-resistant.
In each Mimic film, there is an ironic yet parallel connection between the human protagonists and the Judas Breed:
* In Mimic, even though Dr. Tyler saved countless children through her research and her scientific offspring of genetically modified insects have become much more fertile than she intended, she herself is unable to conceive a child with her husband, Dr. Peter Mann (Jeremy Northam). In contrast, her Judas Breed creations reproduce with great success, even though they were intended to die off after they served their original purpose.
* In Mimic 2, Remi cannot find a boyfriend who understands her but nevertheless cannot shake the sexual designs of a male Judas Breed insect--a suitor that Remi understands better than her human suitors because of her background in entomology. This plot of cross-species attraction is an extension of both the Judas Breed's transgenic creation and the fertility/infertility theme from the first movie. Remi's habit of taking photos of her own face when she is dumped is also paralleled in the lone Judas Breed's ability to attach the faces of its victims--the same people who dumped Remi--to its exoskeleton for better mimicry of people.
* In Mimic 3, Marvin survives Strickler's Disease only to become an asthmatic bubble boy stuck in his room, while the very things that ended the Stricker's epidemic are freely roaming the streets and systematically slaughtering Marvin's neighbors.
Another recurring irony in the Mimic movies is photography. The films' protagonists use photography to identify the presence of the Judas Breed menace. This theme complements the Judas Breed's capability for deception, that the human eye cannot be trusted to identify such well-hidden threats. However, the characters' reliance on photography to find the monsters also indicates that technology is more adept at noticing environmental problems than humans; in other words, humans are so far removed from the natural world that we need technology to identify when our technology wreaks havoc with nature.
Plot details aside, the pervasive ironies in the Mimic series allows for commentary on some real issues:
Genetic Modification: Even though the Mimic monsters in reviews and plot summaries are referred to as "giant cockroaches", the Judas Breed are a hybrid of cockroaches, preying mantises, and termites; to use real-world terminology, the Judas Breed are genetically modified organisms (GMOs), particularly one of a transgenic variety. The plot device of elaborate, inter-species genetic splicing is supposed to give plausibility to the Judas Breed's later changes in size and shape, as if to say that humanity's tampering with the genetic code of several insect breeds somehow (to use firearms terminology) took the safety off of nature's mandated order of gradual mutation and evolution. The notion that genetic tampering could result in uncontrollable dangers is further emphasized in the first Mimic film when the Judas Breed were supposed to self-terminate shortly after they fulfilled their purpose--thus limiting their environmental impact to only the cockroaches that served as a vector for the propagation of Strickler's Disease--but instead propagated out of control.
Anti-Vaccination Fears: By intertwining the creation and existence of the Judas Breed with Strickler's Disease--as well as making children frequent victims of the giant insects in all three films--bears symbolic similarities to recent efforts by the anti-vaccination movement. In other words, scientific solutions designed to protect children from disease that in turn endangers them is the underlying premise of the both Mimic trilogy and anti-vaccination paranoia. Coincidentally, the MMR (mumps-measles-rubella) vaccine has been accused of promoting autism, while the only child who survives a close encounter with the Judas Breed in the first Mimic film is obviously autistic.
On a deeper level of irony, director Guillermo del Toro uses Christian imagery throughout the first film to argue that scientists "shouldn't play God" in spite of their efforts to fight a child-killing disease (as if the name "Judas Breed" wasn’t enough of a nod to religious themes). In contrast, some people actually use their religious beliefs as a reason to either exempt their children from vaccinations or to justify denying them medical treatment. Del Toro does not specify in his film when science actually should intervene in the natural order to save lives (you'd think he'd be more sympathetic to the Dr. Tyler character for all of the lives she saved as the result of her work), and the parents in the real world who refuse to immunize or give proper medical care to their children for religious reasons have not offered any remedies to when children die as the result of such beliefs.
Urbanization and Species Displacement: While the underclass are usually the victims of the urban-dwelling Judas Breed monsters, many animals have been reported raiding dumpsters in large cities. Some animals normally thought of as wild (such as raccoons and monkeys in India) have become "urban wildlife", animals that are extremely adept at adjusting their behavior to exist in large cities--essentially, the real-world Judas Breeds. The supreme irony that permeates the Mimic trilogy is that the genetically-engineered bugs are much better suited to survive and thrive in filthy, disease-ridden urban environments than the people who built and live in them. In a biological sense, New York City is more of a home to the Judas Breed than its human inhabitants, suggesting that it is humanity that will be displaced from the world of its own making.
Social Class and Technology: Because each of the films takes place in dirty, impoverished, and neglected urban environments, they provide an opportunity for commentary on social class, particularly how poor urban minority communities suffer from disproportionately higher rates of illness due to prolonged exposure to man-made toxins. In the trilogy, there are hints of an allegorical link between the poor and the scientifically-engineered Judas Breed, an allegory that is akin to the Eloi-Morlok relationship in another H.G. Wells' novel, The Time Machine. Where Wells' story portrays the upper and lower classes evolving into different species to the point where the once-exploited now live underground and feed off of the descendants of the exploiters, the Mimic movies show the upper class promising amazing solutions to complex problems, but once the solutions go underground and out of the public eye they ultimately cause more suffering among the underclass. The theme of linking of urban lower class suffering caused by corrupted technology is also found in the cult horror films such as C.H.U.D. and Street Trash.
While the Mimic movies are very inaccurate in their portrayal of how scientific research actually works and what insects are capable of doing in terms of their biology, they nevertheless provide opportunities to examine the larger implications on humanity's relationship with corrupted scientific research and its results. If anything, the relationship between the camouflaged Judas Breed and their human prey are similar to modern problems that stem from science, technology and industry and our relationship to them: they are familiar but indistinguishable shadows against the dimly lit horizon, vague shapes in the periphery that do not make their true forms known until they are standing directly in front of us. If horror films such as the Mimic trilogy can stimulate further discussion on real problems, one can only hope that the most horrifying of technological terrors will remain limited to the silver screen.