Great Moments in Mystery Box Storytelling: Close Encounters of the Third Kind (1977)
Back in 2007, director J.J. Abrams gave a TED talk where he praised what he called "mystery box" storytelling. To him, a mystery box of a narrative represent hope, potential, and infinite possibility (his words). In the years since his talk, geeks have used Abrams' own words against him whenever he used an element of mystery to buttress weak stories (as he did in Lost , Super 8 , his Star Trek movies, Star Wars: The Force Awakens , etc.). There's nothing wrong with using a bit of mystery to stir an audience's imagination and keep them engaged in a story; likewise, storytellers don't necessary have to answer all of the questions that they raise in order to tell satisfying stories. On the other hand, explicitly building a narrative around questions that are either never answered or only provide lackluster resolutions provides more frustration than entertainment, something that I don't think Abrams understands yet. Still, you have to cut Abrams s...